Introduction
Ride-hailing services are the trending public transportation solution in major African cities, and since their advent, have offered innovative transport services which appeal to the continent’s teeming population, especially the youth. Ride-hailing platforms (including Uber, Bolt, etc.,) have successfully displaced traditional means of public transportation (taxis, buses, and to a certain degree, commercial motorcycles [1]) in these African cities. They offer convenience and fair pricing, which is attractive to customers. It also appeals to those who – for health and safety reasons and sometimes, time constraints – prefer private transportation.
Government Regulatory Approach
Expectedly, this seemingly disruptive business model requires a modernised regulatory approach targeting issues including licensing, the protection of personal data, taxation, health, safety, etc. In this article, we briefly examine the regulatory approach deployed in three African Countries (Nigeria, Kenya and South Africa) and how these are expected to shape the regulation of this business model across the continent.
Health and Safety
Concern for passenger safety came to the fore in 2017 when London’s transport authority – Transport for London (TfL) suspended Uber’s license citing “a pattern of failures” by the company including breaches that allowed unauthorised drivers to operate on the Uber platform. The manner of enforcement action and approach adopted in this circumstance has led to notable improvements in service delivery by ride-hailing companies in this and other western jurisdictions.
Following suit, government agencies in some African countries have found it necessary to enact laws addressing safety concerns for ride-hailing operations in their jurisdictions. For instance, the Lagos State Government (Nigeria) in August 2020 issued the Guidelines for Online Hailing Business Operation of Taxis in Lagos State, 2020 (the “Guidelines”). These Guidelines aim, amongst other things, to enhance the safety and security of lives and property within the State’s transportation network and to develop a robust database of the operators, drivers and passengers.
Kenya’s National Transport and Safety Authority (NTSA) regulates the ride-hailing sector through the Transport and Safety Act No. 33 of 2012. The NTSA relied on this law to ban the operation of two ride-hailing services for lack of proper registration. For more specific regulation, the Kenyan government has introduced a draft regulation that covers licensing for ride hailing platforms and drivers. Until the bill’s passage, the country’s ride-hailing model is expected to fit within existing legislative structures.
In South Africa, the proposed National Land Transport Amendment Bill [2] is specific to operators and participants in the ride-hailing sector and covers issues such as licensing, health and safety of operators and passengers. Health and safety concerns in the bill include licensing requirements, vehicle standards, transport routes, identity disclosures before boarding, etc.
Data Privacy and Protection
The Nigeria Data Protection Regulation 2019 (NDPR) and the Kenyan Data Protection Act 2019 contain similar data privacy provisions that apply to ride-hailing services. Regulatory standards set by these laws entail the protection of customers’ personal data from theft or unauthorised access, adherence to lawful basis for data processing, standard retention policies and the preservation of customers’ privacy rights. Some ride-hailing companies (including Uber) started their operations in European countries where the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) applies. As such, they are expected to maintain basic data privacy standards.In Lagos, Nigeria for instance, the Guidelines grant the State’s Ministry of Transportation access to the database of the ride-hailing companies operating within the State. This raises valid concerns about data privacy. These concerns have been raised by impacted stakeholders and should, hopefully, be adequately addressed.
Taxation
In Kenya, recent amendments to the Finance Act 2019 and Tax Laws Act 2020 brought ride-hailing companies and their operators under the country’s tax base. The amendments impose income tax on “income accruing through a digital marketplace”, and Value Added Tax to services rendered through a digital marketplace. Further, being part of the digital economy, ride-hailing services are now liable to withholding tax under the Tax Laws Act 2020. The amendment in the Finance Act also proposes a 1.5% digital tax on online transactions, 1% gross sales tax, and a minimum tax, if the tax payable is less than 1% of the Company’s gross turnover.
In Nigeria, amendments introduced by the Finance Act 2020 to Section 13(2) of the Companies Income Tax Act, make ride-hailing companies liable to Companies Income Tax in line with the international digital taxation principle of “significant economic presence”. The Finance Act also extends Value Added Tax liability (of 7.5%) to suppliers of goods and services in the digital economy and an Electronic Money Transfer Levy where payment for ride-hailing services is made through any digital platform. Apart from the above general tax regime, the Lagos State Guidelines impose a 10% service tax on transportation fares paid by passengers.
Labour Considerations
Since inception, ride-hailing companies have described their drivers as independent contractors [3]. The implication of this is that drivers are not entitled to labour, social security (where applicable) and healthcare protection and benefits.
Under Kenyan law, there is currently no specific employment law coverage for drivers on ride-hailing platforms. Drivers are regarded as independent contractors and are not entitled to usual employee packages such as sick or annual leave, health cover, or pension contributions. The same position obtains in Nigeria.
In 2016, the London Central Employment Tribunal held in Aslam and Others v Uber BV and Others, that drivers engaged by Uber were not self-employed contractors but fall within the legal definition of a “worker” under local UK. legislation. In February 2019, the UK.’s Supreme Court upheld this judgment, entitling these drivers to employment rights. Impelled by this decision, groups of ride-hailing drivers in South Africa filed a Class Action suit at the Johannesburg Labour Court, seeking an improvement of their labour conditions and claiming employment rights including compensation for unpaid overtime and holiday pay. A favourable judgment may result in a replication in other African countries.
In summary, it can be observed that the governments in some African countries are following global trends in this sector and proposing legislation tailored towards minimal interference while ensuring safety and protection of operators and the public at large. It would not be surprising therefore to observe more robust (and in some cases, stringent) regulations as this business model gains more public acceptance in the future.
Notes:
[1] Gokada in Nigeria and Safeboda in Kenya are examples of the successful adoption of the ride-hailing business model by motorcyclist and online delivery companies.
[2] The Bill is awaiting Presidential Assent.
[3] It is however important to note that judicial decisions on this matter may differ from what the parties intend.
THIS ARTICLE IS WRITTEN BY LEXWORTH LEGAL PARTNERS
Authors: Tochukwu Itumo and Adeyinka Salami
I’m extremely impressed together with your writing talents and also with the format to your weblog. Is that this a paid subject or did you customize it your self? Either way keep up the excellent high quality writing, it’s rare to peer a nice blog like this one today!
Explore the vibrant Miami party bus scene with diverse rental options. Visit bestmiamipartybus.com for rentals and services. Find the perfect party bus in Miami, FL, for any occasion, ensuring a memorable and stylish transportation experience tailored to your needs.
Celebrate your homecoming in style with our Homecoming Limo Miami service. We offer Homecoming Limo Rentals Miami that provide luxury and comfort. Choose our Miami Homecoming Limo Service for Affordable Homecoming Limos in Miami and unforgettable transportation experiences.
Planning a celebration? Choose Party Bus Miami! Our birthday party bus Miami and prom party bus Miami options are perfect for unforgettable parties. Kids will enjoy the ride on our kids party bus Miami, while adults love the beach fun in a Miami Beach party bus or dancing in a party bus with pole Miami.
For an epic celebration, book your Miami Bachelor Party Bus Rental now. Our fleet includes stylish Miami Bachelor Party Limo options and party-ready Bachelor Party Bus Miami vehicles. Enjoy seamless Miami nightlife transportation and top-tier amenities. Make your night unforgettable with Luxury Limo Service Miami and a VIP Bachelor Party Limo vibe.
Explore Maryland’s array of bus companies offering reliable group transportation services across the state. Whether for corporate events or leisurely trips, discover efficient options to suit your needs. Elevate your journey with KV Limo’s luxurious transportation offerings and personalized service.
Luxury awaits with Bahamas Limousines. Plan your wedding day with Bahamas limo service for weddings, enjoy chauffeur-driven Bahamas limousines, or explore with private limo tours in Bahamas and top-rated luxury limousine rental Bahamas.
We provide exceptional Baha Mar Transportation via our trusted Private Airport Shuttle Baha Mar. Whether you’re visiting for work or leisure, you’ll enjoy luxury, professionalism, and efficiency on every transfer from Nassau Airport.
Owen Sound Taxi offers dependable transportation in Owen Sound, Ontario. With a commitment to safety and efficiency, our services cater to both residents and visitors, ensuring a comfortable and reliable commuting experience in the area.
Woodstock’s go-to transportation solution, Woodstock Taxi, and its reliable Woodstock Taxis. We ensure safe and efficient travel in Woodstock, Ontario, catering to both locals and tourists alike.
For premium comfort, book a Private Airport Shuttle Muskoka today. Our Airport Shuttle Muskoka to Toronto Pearson ensures direct and stress-free transfers. Looking for exclusivity? Our Toronto Pearson to Muskoka Private Shuttle Service is tailored to your needs. Enjoy a smooth journey with our well-maintained fleet.
Indulge in ultimate sophistication with Dubai Limousine Rental Services. Limo Rental Dubai features top luxury cars, including Hummer and Rolls Royce models. Rent a Limousine in Dubai and enjoy dependable and stylish Dubai Limo Services perfect for any occasion.
Step into a world of elegance with Rolls Royce Taxi Dubai. From Rolls Royce Wedding Taxi Dubai to Rolls Royce Airport Taxi Dubai, our chauffeur service defines luxury. Get reliable Dubai Rolls Royce Taxi Booking for business, leisure, or VIP occasions across the UAE.
Experience the best of comfort and class with Mercedes for Rent in Dubai. Our Dubai Mercedes Rental Service includes Mercedes S Class Rental Dubai with professional Mercedes Chauffeur Dubai. Rent Luxury Mercedes Car Dubai for smooth, stylish, and elite rides.
Elevate your airport experience with our comprehensive O’Hare Airport Pickup/Drop Service. Offering shuttle pickups, limousine transfers, and chauffeur-driven rides, we prioritize punctuality, professionalism, and comfort for every traveler’s needs.
Black Tie Transport offers reliable shuttle service from Rancho Cucamonga to LAX, featuring affordable LAX shuttle options, private car services, and luxury transportation. With airport shuttle options, SUV transportation, and seamless Rancho Cucamonga airport transfers, choose Black Tie for a comfortable and efficient airport experience to LAX and beyond.
Our main priority is to provide comfort, and elegance in our luxury cars and limousines. Our goal is to offer seamless airport transfers in Dubai for both personal and professional trips.
Unleash fun and excitement with Miami Party Bus Services. Perfect for proms, weddings, and bachelorette parties, our Luxury Party Bus Miami offers premium comfort. Experience the Best Party Bus Rentals Miami for any celebration!
Take your event to the next level with Miami limo rentals. Whether it’s a wedding limo service Miami, sweet 16 limo Miami, or prom night limo Miami, we provide top-tier luxury limo rental Miami with chauffeur service Miami for an elegant ride.
Looking for the perfect send-off? Try the Miami Bachelorette Party Bus. Our pink party bus Miami features lights and music, while the luxury bachelorette bus Miami offers elegance. Bachelorette party bus rental Miami made easy, with options for every budget and VIP bachelorette bus Miami touches.
Whether club-hopping or cruising the beach, our Miami Bachelor Party Bus Rental makes it memorable. Choose from a wild Bachelor Party Bus Miami or elegant Miami Bachelor Party Limo. Enjoy top-tier Miami nightlife transportation and a fun-filled ride with friends. Trust our Luxury Limo Service Miami for a VIP Bachelor Party Limo night.
At Airport Transfers Bahamas, luxury and safety come standard. Our premium fleet is built for your comfort and meets the highest vehicle safety requirements for worry-free travel.
Reach Atlantis from Nassau Airport with professional transfer services offering comfort and timeliness. Our Atlantis to Airport rides ensure a smooth journey back with well-maintained vehicles and friendly chauffeurs dedicated to your satisfaction.
Reliable transportation from Waterloo to Pearson Airport is at your fingertips. Choose Waterloo Taxi for punctual and comfortable rides, whether you prefer a taxi, airport limo, or top-notch airport transportation service.
Woodstock Taxi services offer reliable transportation in Woodstock, Ontario. With a fleet of Woodstock Taxis, we ensure efficient and safe commuting for residents and visitors. Count on us for all your local transportation needs.
Choose Peterborough to Pearson Airport Shuttle for all your airport transportation needs. With Airport Shuttle Peterborough, Airport Taxi Peterborough, and Limo Service Peterborough options, you’ll enjoy a reliable and comfortable ride to Pearson Airport. Whether it’s an Airport Transfer or Shuttle to Toronto Airport, we offer punctual and professional service.
With a distance of 30 kilometers, traveling from Dubai Airport to Atlantis The Palm takes about 30-45 minutes. Taxis offer efficiency, while limo services provide a luxurious way to start your stay in Dubai.
Enjoy comfort and class with our Luxury Van Rental Dubai. Whether for business or leisure, our Dubai Luxury Group Transport and Executive Van Service Dubai offer top-tier comfort. Ride in sophistication with our Private Van Rental Dubai options and benefit from exclusive VIP Van Hire Dubai features.
LAX to ONT Shuttle or Ontario to LAX Shuttle—whatever your travel needs, we offer reliable airport transfers. Whether from Chino, Fontana, or directly from Ontario Airport, our team ensures smooth and timely service for every journey.